"Chris thinks so, too, but it's just a hobby," she said, dismissing the compliment.

"When did you start painting?" Jessie asked.

"Oh, I always dabbled, just with charcoal at first. I guess you were probably five when I started with paint."

"I never knew that."

"No, I don't suppose you did," Annie said quietly. They stared at each other for a moment, then Annie looked away. That wasn't fair, she thought.

The old Jessie would have lashed out, but she held her tongue. That would be no way for them to start.

"I like the one you gave Chris. Sierra  Peak."

"Oh, that fool! She hung it where everyone could see," Annie said.

Jessie noticed her discomfort and thought she was embarrassed over her paintings. Well, you're always your own worst critic.

"I was actually going to ask you for one for myself," she said, surprising even herself with that admission. "I suppose you find that hard to believe, after the way I left here, after what I said to you on that last day."

"Yes," Annie nodded. "I hope you're not here to carry out your threat."

"I'm really sorry I said that," Jessie said softly. She sank onto the sofa, taking her wineglass with her. She was thankful she had it now.

"Jessie, you don't have to apologize. You were a child. It was as much my fault as anyone's."

Jessie shook her head. "You were never around. Jack said it was because you didn't care about us. He said you didn't like it here in the mountains, that was why you never went with us."

It was Annie's turn to shake her head. "I wouldn't have stayed here all these years if I didn't like it. From the first day he brought me here, I knew I had come home," she said.

"So it's true what Chris said? Jack wouldn't allow you to come with us?"

"Jack loved you very much, Jessie. I think he just wanted you all to himself."

"Why did you let him?"

"Jack was a strong man, Jessie. He could be very persuasive," Annie said, meeting Jessie's dark eyes, so much like her father's.

"He hit you?" she asked, her words barely more than a whisper.

Annie was about to deny it. She had never told Roger and certainly not Chris. But what good would denying it do? If they were here to talk about the past, no sense beginning that with a lie.

"A few times," she admitted. "But I was a very quick learner," she said, a touch of the old bitterness returning. She saw Jessie pale and wondered what thoughts were going through her mind. "He never hit you, did he?" she asked quickly.

"He never hit me, no." She raised her eyes to Annie. "Why did he hit you?"

"Why? I didn't obey him, I guess. The first time was when I tried to breast feed and he insisted I use a bottle. Then again, once, when I took you to Sacramento with me shopping. You were barely two, I think. We were late getting back and he was worried, I guess. The last time he hit me was when I took you out walking on one of the trails. You were, I don't know, four or five. He told me that I was never to take you out again. That was his job to take you out." She stared into the fire. After all these years, she didn't think that it would be so hard for her to remember, but she still felt the pain that she endured as a young mother.

"I'm sorry I didn't stand up to him, Jessie. But by that time, you were following him everywhere and it didn't seem to matter to you, anyway."

Jessie couldn't meet her eyes and she, too, looked into the fire.

"I don't have any memories of you ever doing anything with me. Was that the last time?"

"Oh, yes," Annie nodded. "After that, he started getting you ready for school, tucking you in at night and taking you with him every chance he got. I was here to cook and clean and do laundry. It was around that time that we stopped sleeping together and he moved into the spare room."

"He had... other lovers?"

"He had women, yes. But it wasn't like we had been intimate, Jessie. We hadn't... slept together in years."

Annie got up suddenly and went into the kitchen. She'd had enough talk of Jack for the moment and she found it very uncomfortable talking this way in front of Jessie, who was practically a stranger to her. She could confide in Chris without worrying about her reaction. But Annie wondered if Jessie, subconsciously or on some deep level, might believe she was lying about Jack. He was dead and his story buried with him.

"Annie?" Jessie followed her into the kitchen and she watched now as Annie's trembling hand poured more wine.

"I just needed to check on the bread," she lied.

"I'm sorry. I didn't mean to come here and talk about him, really," Jessie said.


"Yes, you did, Jessie. We need to talk about him. He's all we have between us," Annie said. "And you probably think I'm lying about all of this. To you, he was a wonderful man. Unfortunately, I never got to see that side of him." She turned and lifted the lid on the pot and stirred. "Well, I shouldn't say never. He was very nice to me when we were courting and when we first got married. But that was so long ago, Jessie."

"Why didn't you ever talk to me about all of this?"

"Oh, Jessie, you were too young at the beginning to understand. Then, later, well, you idolized your father. There was nothing I could say then. You would never have believed me."

"Why did you stay with him? Why didn't you leave?"

Annie turned and met her eyes. They were open and trusting, so she let the words come.

"I was afraid... for you," she said quietly.

"For me?"

"Jack had an unnatural interest in you, Jessie. And as you got older, I was so afraid he would... abuse you."

"Sexually?" Jessie whispered.

"Yes. And I couldn't leave you. I didn't know if you would come to me for help, but if you needed someone, who else would you go to?"

Jessie felt her eyes prick with tears and she tried to blink them back, but they came anyway. Annie had been here for her and Jessie never knew it. Sobs shook her shoulders as she remembered his words. "It'll be our little secret. You’re my best girl."

"What is it, child?" Annie walked to her and grabbed her shoulders. "What?"

"He did," Jessie stammered between her tears.

"He did what?"

"He..."

Annie stared at her, realization dawning of what she was trying to say.

"Oh, no, Jessie," Annie whispered. She took the crying woman into her arms, the woman who was her daughter, and held her. "Oh, no."

Jessie leaned into the comfort of her arms, then just as quickly pulled away. She wiped at the tears on her face, unable to meet Annie's eyes. She had to finish. If she didn't get it out now, then when?

"I blamed you," she said. "Jack said you weren't there for him and I believed him. And I resented you for what he was doing to me but, I couldn't make him stop. And so I just blocked it out. And when he died, I had to get away from you, from here. I hated you so much," she whispered. "So I ran. I ran from my life here and I buried all of that away and pretended that it never happened. And then it didn't happen. I didn't remember it anymore. I was ten," she said. "That's the last time I remember being a kid. After that..."

Annie tried to hold her tears back, but she couldn't. That bastard! She tried to reach out to Jessie, but Jessie moved away.

"No. Let me finish," she said. "I need to finish."

Annie nodded, unable to speak.

"I was never able to let anyone get close to me. I didn't have friends. Even in college, I was always alone. And sex became a game to me. It wasn't for pleasure, not mine or theirs. It was an act performed as some sort of ritual, I think. Over the years, it became that, anyway. But I didn't really know why. I started seeing a therapist after college and that's when I realized that I couldn't remember anything anymore. All I held on to was my hate and resentment for you. And the only reason I could come up with was that I blamed you for his death. I always had my memories of my childhood and they were happy and he was there. But you never were. I've seen six or seven therapists over the years and none of them could help me. When Dr. Davies suggested I come back here and see you and maybe find answers, I couldn't deny that I wanted to come back. I so badly wanted my life back.

"I met Chris out on Ridge Trail. We became... friends. She knew that I couldn't remember. She said some things about you, told me some things that you had told her, and bits and pieces started coming back. But Annie, I didn't want them to come back. Not when I realized what it might be. But they came and I remembered everything and I just wanted... to die."

"Jessie ..."

"And when I remembered, I couldn't stay here another minute. I had to get away."

Annie didn't know what to say, so she said nothing. She just watched this woman with tears in her eyes stare back at her.

"I spent two weeks alone in my apartment. I went back over everything and I realized that I wasn't to blame and you weren't to blame. It was just him," she said quietly. "And so I had to come back to see you. To tell you why I left all those years ago."

When Annie reached out this time, Jessie didn't pull away. She cleared her throat before speaking, hoping her voice would follow.

"I'm so, so sorry. I should have realized. Maybe deep down, I..."

"No. You can't blame yourself. It was him, not you."

"Now what do we do?"

"I don't know. I honestly don't know," Jessie said. "Is it too late to start over?"

"Of course not. You can stay here with me," she said without thinking.

But Jessie shook her head.

"I don't think so, Annie. Neither of us are ready for that. I've got a cabin rented until mid-December."

"Mary Ruth's?"

"Yes."

"Is it close to Chris?"

"Yes."

"Good. She can be a good friend, Jessie. She has been to me."

"I know. I probably wouldn't be here today if I'd never met her," Jessie admitted. But she didn't know if Chris wanted to be a friend to her anymore.

"She came back here yesterday, after she took you home," Annie said. "She was worried about me."

Jessie nodded. "I thought she might."

"She told me a little about your time here in August. I think she's worried about you, too."

Jessie nodded. Maybe.

"I've had about enough for one day, Jessie. How about lunch?"

"Yes." Jessie, too, felt drained. And relieved. She had been preparing herself for this day for nearly two months and it had been easier than she thought it ever could be. Annie had simply accepted everything she had to say and expected no other explanations. They could never undo what Jack had done, but they could start fresh with each other.

"The table is already set. Just grab yourself a bowl there," she said, pointing to the two stacked on the counter.

They filled their bowls and took them into the dining room, where Annie had already placed hot French bread. Jessie had taken several bites before she realized there was no meat in the stew.

"Are you a vegetarian?"

"Yes. It'll do you good," she said, motioning to the stew.

"For how long?"

"Nearly seventeen years now," she said with a smile.

"No wonder Chris enjoys having dinner with you," Jessie said.

"Well, I like to think it's my company as well as my cooking."

"I didn't mean it like that, Annie," Jessie said quickly. "I know how Chris feels about you."

"Yes, Chris and I get along well, despite the differences in our ages. She's been very kind to me. Roger Hamilton brought her around one day. Do you remember Roger?"

"Yes. Has he been here all these years?"

"Oh, no. He went to Tahoe for awhile. Then Yellowstone. When he came back here, he looked me up. He was a lifesaver," she said.

"Chris says you don't go into town," Jessie stated.

"No. I withdrew for awhile, and it became a habit. If I needed something, I went to Sacramento or San Francisco. Then Roger came back and started bringing me groceries and I made fewer and fewer trips to the city. But it was my choice, Jessie. I've managed."

There were so many things Jessie wanted to ask, but she thought she would save that for another day. After lunch, Annie asked if she wanted to look around the house, but Jessie declined. She wasn't ready for that.


Chapter Thirty

Chris and Roger were sharing a booth at the Rock House. Chris shoved her plate away and reached for her beer instead. It had been a slow day. She and Bobby had taken their cross-country skis out, but there wasn't enough snow in most places to actually ski. The clear skies and rising temperatures had turned the snow to slush and they ended up hiking back down in their ski boots.