“I condescended,” she said, her voice jerky and rather breathless. “I condescended to his level. And then, when I went to London on one occasion because he was there, he let me know that he was not pleased. And then he started avoiding me even at Fincham and finally told me it was all over between us. The presumption, Peter. The humiliation! You must understand. I loved your papa, but my life was very empty without him. I was willing to allow that man…”

Ah, just the explanation she had given five years ago when he had confronted her.

“You drove him to his death,” he said quietly. He felt physically sick.

“He was foolish!” she cried. “He must have known that I was just upset with him, that I would not really have ruined him.”

“And yet,” he said, “after he had been to Sir Charles and confessed about his past, you were very ready with new threats.”

“I would not have-” she began.

“Wouldn’t you?” he asked her. “He obviously thought you would. He staked his life on it.”

She spread her hands over her face, and he sat staring at her, appalled at what he had learned today, at what he had guessed, at what she had now confirmed. And at the knowledge that she had twice been prepared to wreak havoc with other people’s lives because of her sexual needs and her loneliness.

He hated to think of his own mother in such a way.

Was this one of the dragons he must fight? If so, the price was high indeed. Nothing would ever be the same. But the same as what? He had brushed much beneath the metaphoric carpet five years ago. He would do so no longer.

“You do not know how I have suffered, Peter,” she said, tearful now-as she had been the last time. “If he did it for revenge, he certainly had the final word. Do you think I have not felt like a murderer all these years? But it is unfair. I did not mean him any harm. I was fond of him. I have always been your mother, and I know it is hard to see your own mother as a woman. But I am a woman, and I was lonely. We were both widowed. He had loved his wife as I loved your father. He even told me at the end that he could not continue with me because his heart had broken at her death and he could not forget her. But for a time we were almost happy. We were not hurting anyone.”

He almost felt sorry for her. She had done something monstrous, but she was surely not a monster. And the worst thing about her monstrosity must always have been that she could not atone-Osbourne was dead. Would she have brought false accusations against him if he had lived? There was no way of knowing, and he did not want to know. But she had done irreparable harm anyway.

He was very tempted to get up, to take her hands in his and draw her to her feet and into his arms, to comfort and reassure her, to send her off to bed. But he had done that the last time, after Grantham. If she needed forgiveness, it was her own she must seek, not his.

Besides, there was one more thing he needed to say, and it was best to say everything now tonight and hope that tomorrow they could both start piecing their lives back together.

She spoke before he could, though.

“Peter,” she said, “you cannot marry his daughter. You must see that. It would be an impossible, horrible situation.”

He drew a slow breath.

“And yet it would have been perfectly fine for me to marry Bertha?” he asked her.

She did not reply.

With the commonsense part of his mind he agreed with her, though. The past would always be there between him and Susanna, the knowledge that his mother and her father had been lovers, that she had caused his death. It would be far better to allow Susanna to return to Bath, to go to London himself after Christmas and set his mind to choosing a suitable bride during the Season. Eventually they would forget each other, and when they did remember, they would both be glad they had not taken a chance on happiness.

But he had renounced simple common sense since leaving Bath behind him a few weeks ago. He was reaching for happiness, or if happiness proved impossible, then at least for self-respect. He would no longer avoid the darker corners of his life.

It was altogether possible-even probable-that Susanna would not have him after all, but he would not lose her just because he had chosen to tiptoe his way past his dragons. Even after she was gone he would have to live with himself. And finally he was determined to like the person who lived inside his body.

Not that he particularly liked himself at the moment.

“The only question to be settled on the issue of Miss Osbourne, Mama,” he said, “is whether she will marry me under the circumstances. She has already refused me once.”

She looked sharply at him with a curious mixture of indignation and hope on her face.

“Mama,” he said after drawing a deep breath, “I want Sidley to become my home.”

She stared at him.

“It is yours, Peter,” she said. “If you do not spend more time here, it is your own fault. You know how often I have urged you to come.”

“Because it has always been more yours than mine,” he said.

“Sidley has been yours since you were an infant,” she said. “I have always kept the household running smoothly for you. I have always kept it beautiful for you. Lately I have begun some refurbishings, all for your sake.”

“But I have never been consulted about anything,” he said.

“Because you are never here, ” she cried.

It was true enough. She did have a point there.

“I ought to have taken over both the house and the estate when I reached my majority,” he said, “but I did not for reasons we need not rehash yet again. I have my own ideas on how both should be run, and now I am ready to implement them. I want to make friends of my neighbors. I want them here for frequent entertainments. I want them to feel welcome, to feel at home here. I want to live here most of the time.”

“Peter,” she said, looking more herself again, “this is wonderful! I shall-”

“I want it for myself, Mama,” he said, “and for my wife and children if I marry.”

She smiled uncertainly at him.

“Perhaps,” he said, “you would like to redecorate and refurnish the dower house and move there when it is ready.”

“The dower house?” Her eyes widened in indignation.

“I have always loved it,” he said. “You could surely be contented there.”

“It is where the governesses and tutors always lived,” she cried.

“Then we will look around for a suitable house for you in London,” he suggested. “There will be company there for you most of the year, and plenty of entertainments, and all the shops. And you will always be welcome here as a visitor.”

She leaned back in her chair and stared at him-and there was a moment at which he was aware that her chin tilted slightly upward.

“I have always lived here in order to keep it for you,” she said. “You are my only son. I took on the responsibility when your father died, and I have not relinquished it since. I have given my life for you.”

It was, he realized, a moment when some rebuilding was possible.

“And I will be eternally grateful,” he said. “I had a marvelously secure childhood. I was never in any doubt that I was loved. And I am glad I did not marry too young. I have had the chance to live out my early manhood and find out who I am and what I want of my life, secure in the knowledge that you and my home were always here for me. But now I have arrived at that point of self-discovery, Mama, and I can set you free to enjoy your life in any way you choose. I know you have been lonely here.”

It was not entirely the truth that he spoke, of course, but there was truth in it nevertheless. And despite everything, he would always love her and always be grateful that she had loved him during his childhood.

“I think,” she said, “I would like to live in London.”

Perhaps she did not speak the entire truth either. And yet it struck him that she probably would be happier there. And there was a certain relief in finding that she had rejected the idea of moving to the dower house.

“We will see to it after Christmas,” he said. “But I have kept you up very late, Mama. You must go to bed now. Tomorrow will be busy, I daresay.”

“Yes.”

But she did not immediately get to her feet.

“Peter,” she said, “I could never love another man as I loved your father. William Osbourne, George Grantham-they meant nothing to me, though I was fond of them both. I certainly did not mean to do anyone any harm.”

“I know you did not.”

He knew no such thing, alas, but it was not his place to pour recriminations on her head. He got to his feet and offered her his hand. When she was standing before him, small, fragile, still lovely, he kissed her forehead and then her cheek.

“Good night, Mama,” he said.

“Good night, Peter.”

She left the room without another word, her back straight, her step light and firm.

He looked toward the brandy decanter but rejected the idea of pouring himself a glass. If he started drinking tonight, he knew he would not stop until he was thoroughly foxed.


Several times during the course of Christmas Eve Susanna thought about Claudia and Eleanor and Lila and the girls who would be at the school for Christmas. They were there right now, she thought. She tried to ground herself in the reality of that thought, but it was hard to believe in it. It was hard to believe anything that was happening around her either.

It was as if she had stepped into some strange dream.

Life had been so routine, so predictable, so dull, until the end of the summer. And yet there had been a certain contentment, even happiness, about the dullness.

Yesterday seemed unreal. Could she really have gone willingly to the dower house at Sidley Park with Viscount Whitleaf? Had she really gone to bed and made love with him there? Twice? The second time entirely initiated by her?

And today, were these strangers with whom she was spending almost all her time really turning so quickly into familiar, even dear, relatives? Was it possible to feel a close familial connection to people of whose very existence she had been hardly aware until yesterday morning?

But her grandfather Osbourne looked so very much as her father would have looked, if he had lived so long, that she would hardly have been able to drag her eyes away from him had her grandmother not had Papa’s eyes-and if she had not insisted upon holding Susanna’s hand much of the time and patting it and gazing at her in fascinated wonder. And her Grandfather Clapton really did have her own eyes, though their color had faded closer to gray than green, and she could imagine, looking at his thin gray hair, that it really had been auburn at one time. He had a way of nodding and smiling quietly, leaving most of the talking to the other two, that drew her eyes and tugged at her heart.

Grandmother and Grandfather Osbourne had no surviving children, and she was their only grandchild. Their lives must have been filled with the most terrible sadness. They had had two sons.

By running away, she thought, she had robbed them of knowing her from the age of twelve until now. But then, they were the ones who had banished her father. Not that she would judge them for that. He had interfered with their elder son’s marriage and then caused his death in a fight. She longed to know details of that fight. Had the death been entirely accidental? Had her father’s brother fallen and hit his head on a stone, for example? But she would not ask.

Her grandfather Clapton had three surviving daughters and eight grandchildren apart from Susanna. Her aunts and cousins, he told her, smiling his quiet smile. The eldest was married to his successor in the village church-and their son was a curate in a church not far away.

She had aunts and uncles and cousins.

“How different my life would have been if I had not left Fincham in such a hurry all those years ago,” she said.

“And ours too, dearest,” her grandmother said, patting her hand.

“But would you go back now and change your life if you could?” Grandfather Clapton asked gently. “I believe our lives unfold in perfect but mysterious ways, understood clearly only by our Lord.”

“That is something you would say, Ambrose,” Grandfather Osbourne said irritably. “I have not seen much perfection in the lives of my own family, only endless mystery. And if the Almighty is responsible, I will have a quarrel to pick with him on Judgment Day.”