She laughed. “No, but definitely not tattoos and pierced eyebrows.”


The bartender delivered our drinks as Cody finished the short, sad song and segued into another tune I didn’t recognize. I felt lucky to have averted my own public breakdown.


Bailey took a long sip of her pineapple juice, then held the glass to her face, joining its moisture with hers. “Is this an antiwar song he’s playing now?”


I listened for a moment. “Oh, it’s ‘Blessed Are the Peacemakers.’ I’ve never heard it on acoustic. Usually, it has these massive, heavy guitars that make you want to start a riot.” I pumped my fist in the air to demonstrate.


“I’m surprised a band like this would be a pacifist. I thought people of faith were supposed to be conservative.”


“Not every Christian is part of the religious right.”


“I know you’re not, but I figured you were the exception.”


“I am in the minority,” I had to admit. “Mara too.”


“Because you guys didn’t grow up in an evangelical church?”


“Maybe.” I took the straw out of my root beer, so I wouldn’t gross her out by nervously chewing on it. “My mom says she wishes we’d discovered a place like Stony Hill ten years ago. Then I wouldn’t ask so many questions.” Still thirsty from dancing, I took a gulp of soda. “She doesn’t get that everyone asks questions. It’s just that most of my friends from church—not all, but most of them—accept the answers.”


“Why?”


“It feels good to know.”


“To know what?”


I shrugged. “To know.”


She sipped her juice and examined me. “Then why do you doubt? Don’t you want to feel good?”


“Because I can’t help it. Besides, this does feel good.” I pointed my straw at the stage, where Cody was strumming the last few chords. Then he took off his guitar and waved before walking offstage to prepare for the encore.


The crowd swelled with applause and cheers. They started chanting, “Thank you! Thank you! Thank you!”


Bailey nudged me. “They do seem really happy. Would you be insulted if I said you seem different from them?”


Meaning “not happy”? I wondered. “Everyone’s different.”


“You’re different in a different way. You seem older. No, ‘older’ is not the right word. Not ‘wiser,’ either, but that’s part of it.”


I looked away, over the crowd of swaying hands. Had Bailey sensed I’d been through a unique hell, the kind no one else we knew had suffered? I thought I’d kept that part of my past hidden, but clearly my walls were missing a few bricks.


“I think the word you’re looking for is ‘studlier,’” I said with a straight face, which collapsed into a grin when she shoved me in the chest.


“Okay, stud, just one more question.” She formed an L with her thumb and index fingers. “Why are some people in the audience holding up the sign for ‘loser’?”


It was my turn to laugh at her. “That’s not for ‘loser.’” I set down my soda, mirrored her gesture with my own hand, then straightened our pinkies to form the sign-language letter. “The L stands for ‘love.’”


“Oh.” Bailey gazed up at me in a way that made my pulse bounce. “I can dig it.”


I smiled at her intentional hippie slang and slipped my arm around her waist. We pressed our Ls together, clasping our other fingers. Then I kissed her, deep enough to taste the pineapple sweet-tartness of her mouth.


And long enough to know: I was seriously falling in L.A week before Thanksgiving, Dad announced he was leaving again, for the third time. But this time, we were prepared.

At 4 a.m. the morning of his departure, I snuck into the garage while Mara kept watch in the kitchen, in case Dad left earlier than his usual hour, around five thirty.

I slid my phone beneath the front passenger seat, then climbed into the van to investigate its contents. The third-row seats were folded down, as usual, but next to the fishing tackle, sleeping bag, and tent lay another large, flat box: Dad’s woodworking tools, which he hadn’t touched since before John died.Wherever he was going, he was building something.

“Please don’t forget to scrub out the litter boxes before I get home for lunch at two,” Mom told us later that morning as she gathered her purse, coffee, and coat for work. “They’re filthy, and I’m tired of reminding you guys. If you each do one, it’ll take less than ten minutes.”

Sitting at opposite ends of the breakfast bar, Mara and I gave her matching yawns and vague assurances.


“Promise!” she said.


“Promise,” we mumbled, shifting our cereal around our bowls as lackluster as possible.


“Honestly,” she muttered on her way to the garage. “You’d think I was asking you to dig ditches in hundred-degree weather.”


The door slammed behind her. We waited as the garage door creaked open. The engine of Mom’s car started, revved, then faded.


Mara and I leaped off the stools. I opened my laptop on the kitchen table while she checked the front window in the living room.


“Confirmed,” she shouted, “Mom’s gone.”


I brought up the website my parents used to track my phone, typed in my number and the password Mom had given me last week. I’d “lost” my phone and had to log in to the site to “make sure” it was at Kane’s, where of course I’d deliberately left it.


“This is kind of hilarious,” Mara said, looking over my shoulder. “Dad installed that app on your phone so he could monitor your every move, and now we’re using it to track him.”


“I hope this trip is short. I want my phone back.”


“You turned off your ringer, right?” she asked.


“I turned off sounds, Wi-Fi, everything I could to save power. Problem is, to keep the GPS running, the phone has to be awake fulltime. So we probably only have eight hours of battery, max.”


She pointed at the screen. Is that little blue man supposed to be you?


“Normally, but now it’s Dad.”


The family minivan—or at least my phone, which should be in the minivan—was currently near Scranton. I hit refresh a few times before determining that the blue man wasn’t moving.


“What the heck’s in Scranton?” I asked Mara.


“Let’s find out.” She grabbed the mouse, zoomed in on the map, then switched to street view. “It’s a rest stop. Breakfast time, I guess.”


We finished our own breakfast, scrubbed the litter boxes, then took turns showering, one of us keeping an eye on the laptop.


When I came back downstairs, Mara was sitting at the table with her books open. She pointed at my laptop. “He’s on the move.”


Over the next six hours, while we tried to focus on calculus and English, the blue man representing my phone (and our father) moved slowly north, then northwest. The farther away it traveled, the slower it went, probably because Dad was driving on smaller and smaller roads, according to the map. With the GPS on, my phone’s battery wouldn’t last much longer.


Finally it stopped in the middle of nowhere in upstate New York, not far from the Canadian border. The map on my laptop showed the road ending at a blob representing a long, narrow, apparently nameless lake.


“There’s no town there,” Mara said as she examined our Rand McNally road atlas, a pencil between her teeth.


“Maybe there’s a town now. That’s a really old map.” So old, it was missing the front and back covers, plus the table of contents and index, plus Alabama and Wyoming.


I brought up a map website and entered the exact coordinates, only to get the same results. “Nothing. Except lots of fish, I guess.”


“That far north, it’d have to be ice fishing. Maybe he just pulled over to take a nap.”


Suddenly the blue man on the tracker screen disappeared, along with the map it was on, replaced by the words “DATA LOST.” “My phone either died or Dad found it and turned it off.”


The door to the garage opened. Mom was home for lunch. Mara slapped shut the atlas, then yanked her calculus homework over it. I switched to a word processing document and started typing madly, frowning at the screen as if in deep thought.


“Hey, David, hey—” Mom stopped halfway across the kitchen and eyed us, her cup of beloved Starbucks halfway to her lips. It was odd for us to be working even in the same room, much less on the same side of the table.


Mara saved us from questions. “Mom, will you please explain the nonrestrictive comma to David? I can’t get through to him.”


This was actually true. Those commas looked so wrong. “My sister, Mara,” instead of “My sister Mara”? It sounded like I should be stopping in the middle of the sentence and bowing to her. Which I would never do.


“You use a comma when there’s only one of a set.” Mom took off her coat, pulling a stray blond-gray hair from the collar before hanging it up. “Like ‘my daughter-comma-Mara.’ When you have more than one, like ‘my s—’” She stopped herself, the corner of her mouth turning down. “Like, ‘my cat Juno,’ there’d be no comma. If you leave out the comma, you’re implying that you have more than one, which could be problematic when referring to a spouse.”


“So I’d say, ‘my girlfriend-comma-Bailey.’”


“I hope so. One is enough to worry about.”


My face warmed. “I’m lucky to have that many.”


“Seriously,” Mara muttered.


Mom laughed and shook her head. “Have you looked in the mirror lately? Just wait until spring when you get on that ball field in front of all the girls.” She opened the refrigerator door halfway. “Is that creepy, to say my son is turning into a hottie?”


Mara whispered, “What’s creepy is you using the word ‘hottie.’”


I choked back a laugh and tugged down the short sleeves of my T-shirt, self-conscious of my biceps. “Thanks, Mom. I think.”


Like Dad, she was unusually chipper these days—obviously, if she could joke about me having multiple girlfriends instead of getting all preachy about purity.


I made a mental note about the comma, but when I was sure Mom wasn’t coming to check my screen, I flipped back to the phone-tracking site. Still no blue man.


I copied the GPS coordinates from the website and into my notebook page.


“Maybe a little.” I tugged down the short sleeves of my T-shirt, self-conscious of my biceps. “But thanks.”


Like Dad, Mom was unusually chipper these days. Come to think of it, ever since he’d started making these trips, they’d both been serene, if not giddy. What was going on?


I made a mental note about the comma, but when I was sure Mom wasn’t coming to look at my screen, I flipped back to the map. Still no blue dot, but at least I’d written down the GPS coordinates. My father was somewhere in that remote wilderness, eight hours away, maybe alone, maybe with fishing buddies, maybe (ugh) with Sophia. It felt wrong to even think it, but his being there made our being here a whole lot easier.

While Mom took Mara to choir practice on her way to show a client some houses, I broke into Dad’s home office. It was an easy job, slipping my brand-new laminated learner’s permit between the doorjamb and the latch.

The room was clean and orderly. Dad would kill me if he knew I’d been in here, so I vowed to move only one object at a time and replace each item exactly as I found it. I also vowed not to get distracted from my search for papers, maps, or pictures dealing with upstate New York.

No distractions meant no rereading that framed Philadelphia Inquirer front page from the Phillies’ World Series win. No admiring the hockey puck that flew off the ice at the Spectrum during the 1975 Stanley Cup Final, giving my then-fifteen-year-old father a mild concussion but also the best souvenir ever. No opening the copy-paper box from the office-supply store that went out of business before I was born, even if it had a “J” neatly printed on the corner.

Don’t look , I told myself as I knelt before it. J could stand for anything. Mom’s name is Jennifer—maybe it’s her stuff. Maybe there are nine other boxes, A through I. Maybe . . .