Madeline Sheehan - Unattainable

Gone were the lip and nose piercings; gone were the hemp necklaces. All that remained were the ear plugs and the tattoos, which he loved.

He’d loved all of it, actually—the Tegen he’d grown up with, the Tegen who’d come home from San Francisco all grown up, and the woman she was now, a sexy, yet quirky combination of both.

For the first time in a year, Cage wished he wasn’t high but at the same time if he wasn’t all fucked-up, he might actually break down and cry like a little girl. And he really didn’t want to do that.

So, in order to avoid all that bullshit, he bent his head and tried to kiss her, but she turned her head away. Panic raced through his overheated system.

“Tegen,” he growled. “Don’t play fuckin’ games with me.”

Her tear-filled eyes filled with angry accusation. “You just fucked that girl, Cage.”

His nostrils flared. “It’s been a year since I’ve seen you.”

Closing her eyes, she shook her head. “I know,” she said. “I just…no more girls, right?”

“You mine?” he asked.

Her eyes flew open, green and shining with emotion. “Yes,” she whispered.

“Then yeah, no more girls.”

“And no more drugs?” she continued.

He nodded. “Yeah.”

“Just me and you?”

“Babe,” he said, his heart pounding. He needed to kiss her now. Right the fuck now or he was going to freak the fuck out.

“Just me and you.”

“Forever.”

“Fucking shit, Tegen, yes, forever. Now shut the fuck up and let me kiss you.”

She shut the fuck up.

And he kissed her.

“I think that’s it,” Ellie called out from the hallway.

Jesus fucking Christ, he hoped so. Dirty had never seen so much shit before in all his life. Who would have thought one woman, a single woman without children, could have accumulated so much fucking shit. He didn’t have half as much shit. Not even a third.

Maybe Ellie moving in wasn’t the best idea. Maybe being with Ellie wasn’t the best idea. Maybe having anything at all to do with Ellie wasn’t the best idea.

“Michael?”

Dirty’s eyes flew open and he found Ellie standing in front of him, holding a large box of books, peering up at him

“Yeah?” he asked, his voice hoarse.

Ellie bent down and set the box near her feet. Standing back up straight, she grabbed both his hands and knowing they were sweaty, clammy with fear, he closed his eyes again, embarrassed.

“Michael,” she whispered. “We don’t have to do this.”

His eyes flew open. No. They did have to do this. He had to do this. He couldn’t sleep even knowing she was at her parents’ house; he was constantly worried about her. True, he laid to rest the threat on her life but there could be another. Someone could snatch her up, hurt her, take her away from him and he wouldn’t even know it was happening, so yeah, he had to do this. He had to have her here with him, living alongside him, sleeping beside him. He had to know where she was at all times and when she wasn’t working, she damn sure needed to be right next to him.

“He can’t hurt me anymore,” she continued. “And if you’re not ready for this—”

“No,” he growled, shaking her grip off him and grabbing her shoulders. “We’re not out of the woods yet. People are fuckin’ talkin’ ’round town. His family’s got money. They keep diggin’, who knows what they’ll find out.”

Ellie pressed her lips together and averted her eyes. She knew he was full of shit. She knew that there was no way anyone was ever going to figure out what had really happened to the good chief of police. Not that there was anything left to find.

“You’re not ready,” she said softly, backing away from him. “And that’s okay.”

Suddenly, Dirty found himself really motherfucking pissed off. Was she fucking scared of him? Was she trying to back out of moving in together? Had this whole thing just been some sort of ploy to get him to break it off because she was scared of what he would do to her if she tried to break it off?

Not that he blamed her. What good woman, or any woman with half a brain, would want to end up with him? He couldn’t even fuck her properly.

“Fuckin’ leave then!” he shouted, kicking her box of books and sending it sliding across the floor. Books flew from the tipped box and ended up scattered across his living room, which only served to piss him off even more.

When she didn’t as much as flinch at his outburst, he grew even angrier. “Get the fuck out, Ellie!” he yelled. “I know that’s what you’re wantin’, so fuckin’ get!”

“That’s not what I want,” she said, staring directly into his eyes, her expression serious. “So stop acting like this.”

Why the fuck was she so fucking calm? He was freaking the fuck out and here she was a picture of cool and collected. That wasn’t fucking fair! Why couldn’t he be normal too? Why couldn’t he be the sort of man, a normal one, a good one, one who deserved to have a woman like this moving in with him, sharing his bed, giving him all sorts of shit he didn’t deserve and never fucking would?

“Get out!” he yelled, sounding every bit as hysterical as he was feeling. He advanced on her, towering over her, and bore down into her personal space. “Did you fuckin’ hear me? I said get the fuck out!”

She didn’t even blink.

“GET OUT!” he roared.

Ellie spun away from him and immediately bent down, reaching for her box. Dirty stood there, shaking, watching as she hurriedly began picking up her books and tossing them into the box. When she was finished, without looking at him, she brushed quickly past him, headed for the door.

No.

He didn’t want this…but he did want this.

He didn’t know…

Shit.

Fuck.

“Fuck!” he yelled, sending his clenched fists into his forehead. “Fuck! Ellie, wait!”

Ellie stopped walking but didn’t turn around and he took a deep breath. “I’m sorry, baby, I’m just, I don’t know, I don’t fuckin’ know, everything is—”

The box fell from Ellie’s hands with a loud thud and then she spun around. Before Dirty had any real time to process what she was doing, she was halfway across the room, unbuttoning her shirt as she stalked toward him.

By the time she reached him, she’d lost her shirt and was in the process of unhooking her bra. Standing in front of him, she tossed the black lace aside and went to work on her black dress pants.

“Sit down,” she ordered as she stepped out of her pants. Her underwear was next and then she was standing before him, naked. He took his time looking down the full length of her, feeling all sorts of ugly thoughts rear up inside of him, mixed in between how beautiful he thought she was, and how desperately he wished he could be with her the way a man was supposed to be with a woman, before meeting her eyes once again.

“Michael,” she said forcefully. “Sit down on the damn couch!”

He didn’t know what she was doing, but he didn’t want her to leave, so he backed away from her slowly until his legs hit the couch. Once he sat down, he looked up at her. Now what?

Now what became suddenly clear when she followed him over and bent down in front of him. Dirty went stiff as her hands reached for his leathers and he fought the urge to slap her away.

“You want me to fuck you,” he said, clenching his teeth. “You coulda just said so.”

Ellie yanked down his zipper. “I don’t want you to fuck me,” she said, sounding angry. Freeing his cock from his boxers, she grabbed hold of him. “I want to fuck you.”

Dirty’s chest heaved hard as fear exploded inside of him. His hands flew to his sides and his fingers dug into the couch cushions. He was getting hard, he didn’t want to be, he would have given anything to cut his own dick off, yet still he was growing harder in her grip.

“What…the…fuck…are…you…doin’,” he said, sounding breathless as if he’d just run a marathon. She knew he couldn’t play it this way, she fucking knew.

He did not want to hurt her. He did not want to hurt his Ellie.

Ellie ignored him as she straddled him. He gripped tighter to the couch cushions and squeezed his eyes shut. “Don’t do this,” he gritted out and then, rather weakly added, “Please.”

But she didn’t stop and once he felt her positioning him at her entrance, he knew she wasn’t going to stop and suddenly it wasn’t just fear that was red-hot, pulsing wildly through him, but it was pain, and he couldn’t breathe and he couldn’t think straight.

“Look at me,” Ellie demanded and when he didn’t, she repeated, “Michael, look at me.”

His jaw locked, his body strung tight, he opened his eyes and tried to focus on her.

“I am not going to hurt you,” she said forcefully.

His vision swam. He needed her off him. Away from him. He needed her to stop fucking touching him.

“Michael!” she yelled. “I’m not going to hurt you! I am not her!”

No. No, no, no, no. That’s what she always told him, that she wasn’t going to hurt him. She promised every time, swore she wouldn’t hurt him, and then she did. She always, always did, she hurt him over and over again until he was crying and screaming and begging her to stop and she never did.

Dirty let out a ragged gasp as Ellie pushed down and he slid slowly inside of her. He was going to kill her; he didn’t want to, but he was going to. He was going to let go of this fucking couch, wrap his hands around her neck, and wring the fucking life from her. He just had to let go of the couch.

“Michael,” he heard her say, her voice soft. “Please look at me and let me show you what love is.”

Air shuddered from his lungs in loud, noisy spurts.

Love.

She had never shown him love.

Ellie wasn’t her.

Ellie was not her.

Ellie was…love.

Not her.

Love.

Dirty tried again to focus on her and when he did, when he really, truly looked at the big blue eyes looking back at him, it was what he didn’t see that startled him back into awareness.

He didn’t see lust. Or need. He didn’t see the hungry gaze of a madwoman. He saw not one trace of pleasure being derived from his pain.

All he saw was Ellie. His Ellie. With tears in her eyes.

“I’m not leaving,” she said. “I’m going to unpack my books and put every single one of them on your empty shelves. I’m going to unpack my clothes and hang them up inside your empty closet. I’m going to fill up your refrigerator with food and your cupboards with dishes and your bathroom with feminine products and I’m going to buy pretty-smelling candles and colorful sheets and curtains and I’m definitely buying a carpet for this big ugly bare room…and I’m going to make you breakfasts and dinners and I’m going to force you to watch stupid movies with me and I’m going to cry and yell once a month for no good reason and I’m going to sleep next to you every night and wake up beside you every morning but most of all, Michael, I’m going to love you. I’m sorry, but you’re just going to have to deal with that, the fact that I need to love you. Because I’m not going to stop, not ever. You did this, you made me love you by just being you and, all my life, everything I’ve ever wanted, I worked hard to get it, and now I want you and I want you to love me and want you to want to be loved in return. Do you understand? I want to love you, not hurt you, not ever hurt you.”

He was shaking now, not out of fear but because he was crying. Because everything she’d just said had been everything he’d always wanted to hear, he just hadn’t realized it. Not until right now.

“Are you going to let me love you?” she whispered.

He swallowed hard. He couldn’t speak; if he tried, he would just end up sobbing, so he nodded instead and Ellie’s beautiful face, her eyes, her mouth, smiled at him in return.

• • •

Lying atop Dirty, Ellie traced the lines of his face. He looked so different when he was sleeping. Peaceful, not tormented. She would give anything to see him look that way while awake. Anything.

He was like a child in so many ways. Everything was new to him and so she’d gone out on a limb, hoping and praying it wouldn’t backfire, and took control much in the way a parent would an out-of-control child. She hadn’t realized it at the time, but while she was trying to save Dirty from himself, by taking control, she’d inadvertently taken back a little piece of what she’d lost at the hands of Daniel.

Kissing his lips softly, so as not to wake him, Ellie climbed off the couch and bent down to retrieve her clothes. As she dressed, she surveyed the apartment, full of her boxes waiting to be unpacked, and shook her head.